UK-Muscle.co.uk Forum banner

Squat 3 x A Week - Overtraining or Not?

7K views 33 replies 20 participants last post by  craftybutcher 
#1 ·
To give myself a change of scenery I'm looking at switching to one of the strength routines, something like Rippetoe's starting strength.

I'm in my forties and wondering if anyone of a similar age has tried the squating three times a week. Does it just lead to overtraining?

I know people are just gonna say 'suck it and see' but wanted to know if anyone had any experience of squating 3 x per week.
 
#8 ·
damon86 said:
I just think if you hit your legs hard enough they need a week to recover and grow.
depends what your training for though. a lot of olympic weightlifters squat twice a day everyday and frequently work upto a 1rm. just depends what your body is used to

for example if you start a job as a labourer you would finish your first day at work you would be really tired and the following morning you would be really aching. However you dont call in sick saying you need the rest of teh week to recover, instead you go to work and get on with it. by end of second you will probably be even more tired and achey but eventually your body will start to get used to the continous workload and you will feel fine again. Same principle applies to lifting imo.
 
#9 ·
gumballdom said:
depends what your training for though. a lot of olympic weightlifters squat twice a day everyday and frequently work upto a 1rm. just depends what your body is used to

for example if you start a job as a labourer you would finish your first day at work you would be really tired and the following morning you would be really aching. However you dont call in sick saying you need the rest of teh week to recover, instead you go to work and get on with it. by end of second you will probably be even more tired and achey but eventually your body will start to get used to the continous workload and you will feel fine again. Same principle applies to lifting imo.
Yeah I agree, the body needs time to adapt to stress.
 
#11 ·
Will101 said:
I find it takes a week for my legs to get over a squats session. Like others have said though, I guess it depends how you structure your training.
In my old routine I would agree... no way could I squat like that more than once a week... not unless the next squat session was light... but on this 5x5 routine I am finding it allows for plenty of recovery and its not a problem...
 
#12 ·
if you chnage one variable 9i.e frequency) then you need to change another (intensity, volume etc)

but I have done a smolov style routine of squatting heavy and hard four times a week and it worked great

in fact i did it for benching and it was the first time i could get through a plataeu which benching once a week had me stuck on for around two years

well structured strength routines would easily allow working a movement or muscle mutliple times per week

the bodybuilder styled routine of killing a bodypart tends to casue problems with doing this - which is better is subjective but i think the more frequent you can train a bodypart and make strength gains the better IMO
 
#14 ·
I'm 39, did about a year of starting strength when 37, I had to read n re read the correct form and get loose enough in the shoulders to place bar in right place and how to squat, but you get strong quick, you just have to remember your focusing on strength and not body building.

Its great though, you keep adding weekly and with 8 months your form is 100% better than ever and your adding iron to the bar to the point you haveto set the pins lower cos the bar bends so much when you step out!
 
#15 ·
Russian Olypmic lifters squat multiple times a day, multiple times per week.

Granted they are the elite, but it shows you what we are capable of.

At 40 you will just have to build up more conservatively. I would also probably suggest monday and friday being 3x5 and weds being a light 2x10 (possibly front squat).

There is no question in my mind though that strength based routines like SS are the absolute best for a newb to the iron game.
 
#16 · (Edited by Moderator)
damon86 said:
I just think if you hit your legs hard enough they need a week to recover and grow.
Only if your bodybuilding and your only goal is to get bigger.

to the OP ive done squatting 3 x a week for many months ann i am currecntly doing it again and it does not lead to overtraining which is why the volume is so low.

if it is done at the correct starting weight, progressed at a slow and reasonable pace, you eat enough food to support your size and strength, you will never overtrain squatting 3x per week.
 
G
#17 ·
gumballdom said:
a lot of strength routines involve squatting multiple times a week. mikex101 on here followed the smolov squat routine and gained very well of it
Certainly did. Legs exploded too.

Will say though, if your going to give it a try, dont think about doing anything other than squatting. Its serious.
 
#18 ·
mikex101 said:
Certainly did. Legs exploded too.

Will say though, if your going to give it a try, dont think about doing anything other than squatting. Its serious.
your not wrong, ive heard of making gains before but jesus the gains i made from squatting 3x per week took the p1ss big time and im not taking just an inch either.

whatever anyone decides, no matter what you platue on or how you do it, never ever sacrifice the squat on these programs for anything, i would say dont even worry about any other bodyparts other than the squat, its the absoloute key on this type of program.
 
#21 ·
As many have said I can summarise as follows :-

Bodybuilding

  • Hit legs with everything once a week to failure.

Strength training

  • Starting Strength , Madcow etc 3x per week not taken to failure

Clearly you can see a guy who fries his legs with everything is going to take a long time to recover. The strength guy can train 3x per week and continue adding weight to the bar.
 
#23 ·
I did a great routine once that bought my legs up very well using x3 per week squatting... monday did olympic style squats, wednesday was front squats, friday pl style squats. Nothing was to failure and volume just a few working sets.

Ironically the other best leg workout i've done was totally different and almost like GVT, with once a week going for pl style squats at 10x10 using a light-ish weight but keeping the rest periods very short.

When seeking strength gains over bodybuilding I like to squat every four days with low-moderate volume and going just below failure... seems to be what works best for me for that particular goal.
 
#24 ·
stone14 said:
could someone quickly post the starting strentgth workout, i have the ebook but i dont have a comp now and theres nothing on this comp im using to view the ebook, thanks alot
Workout A

Squats 5x5

Bench 5x5

Invert row 3xfailure

Press ups 3xfailure

Prone bridges 3x45 seconds

workout B

Squats 5x5

deadlift 1x5

Mili press 5x5

Pullups/chin ups 3xfailure

reverse crunches 3x15

Alternate workout A and B each week for example

Week 1 mon-A, wed-B-, fri-A... Week 2 mon-B, wed-A, fri-B and so on

Add 2.5kg/5lbs each week to squat, bench, deadlift and mili press

Alternate chin ups and pull ups each workout.

And if your wondering the reason for doing 1 set of dead lifts its because using heavy weight it becomes alot harder to keep good form
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top