Robsta

Guy's she's asked a valid question, why the negativity.
Welcome lisa. It does not seem right and I can see what they are saying albeit in a different manner. There is no way he's 23% bf I'm afraid, unless his backside is touching the floor.
He looks lean enough already, if anything I'd say he wanted to bulk up a bit...
Talk to him and make sure you have the correct stats as 23% bodyfat he is not.....by a very long way